OBP-API/obp-api/src/test/scala/code/util/APIUtilTest.scala

/**
Open Bank Project - API
Copyright (C) 2011-2019, TESOBE GmbH.

This program is free software: you can redistribute it and/or modify
it under the terms of the GNU Affero General Public License as published by
the Free Software Foundation, either version 3 of the License, or
(at your option) any later version.

This program is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.  See the
GNU Affero General Public License for more details.

You should have received a copy of the GNU Affero General Public License
along with this program.  If not, see <http://www.gnu.org/licenses/>.

Email: contact@tesobe.com
TESOBE GmbH.
Osloer Strasse 16/17
Berlin 13359, Germany

This product includes software developed at
TESOBE (http://www.tesobe.com/)

  */

package code.util

import java.time.format.DateTimeFormatter
import java.time.{ZoneId, ZonedDateTime}
import java.util.Date

import code.api.Constant
import code.api.util.APIUtil.{DateWithMsFormat, DefaultToDate, theEpochTime, _}
import code.api.util.ErrorMessages._
import code.api.util._
import code.setup.PropsReset
import net.liftweb.common.{Box, Empty, Full}
import net.liftweb.http.provider.HTTPParam
import org.scalatest.{FeatureSpec, GivenWhenThen, Matchers}

class APIUtilTest extends FeatureSpec with Matchers with GivenWhenThen with PropsReset {
  
  val startDateString = DefaultFromDateString
  val startDateStringWrongFormat = "Wrong Date Format"
  val endDateString = DefaultToDateString
  val endDateStringWrongFormat = "Wrong Date Format"
  val inputStringDateFormat = DateWithMsFormat
  val DefaultFromDateString = APIUtil.epochTimeString
  val DefaultToDateString = APIUtil.DefaultToDateString
  val startDateObject: Date = DateWithMsFormat.parse(DefaultFromDateString)
  val endDateObject: Date = DateWithMsFormat.parse(DefaultToDateString)
  ZonedDateTime.now(ZoneId.of("UTC"))

  feature("test APIUtil.dateRangesOverlap method") {
    
    val oneDayAgo = ZonedDateTime.now(ZoneId.of("UTC")).minusDays(1)
    val twoDayAgo = ZonedDateTime.now(ZoneId.of("UTC")).minusDays(2)
    val tomorrow = ZonedDateTime.now(ZoneId.of("UTC")).plusDays(2)
    val dayAfterTomorrow = ZonedDateTime.now(ZoneId.of("UTC")).plusDays(1)
    val formatter = DateTimeFormatter.ofPattern("yyyy-MM-dd'T'HH:mm'Z'")
    
    scenario("Date intervals do not overlap"){
      val interval1 = DateInterval(Date.from(twoDayAgo.toInstant()), Date.from(oneDayAgo.toInstant()))
      val interval2 = DateInterval(Date.from(tomorrow.toInstant()), Date.from(dayAfterTomorrow.toInstant()))
      dateRangesOverlap(interval1, interval2) should be (false)
    }
    scenario("Date intervals overlap"){
      val interval1 = DateInterval(Date.from(twoDayAgo.toInstant()), Date.from(tomorrow.toInstant()))
      val interval2 = DateInterval(Date.from(oneDayAgo.toInstant()), Date.from(dayAfterTomorrow.toInstant()))
      dateRangesOverlap(interval1, interval2) should be (true)
    }
  }
  
  feature("test APIUtil.getHttpRequestUrlParam method") 
  {
    scenario("no parameters in the URL") 
    {
      val httpRequestUrl= "/obp/v3.1.0/management/metrics/top-consumers"
      val returnValue = getHttpRequestUrlParam(httpRequestUrl,"from_date")
      returnValue should be ("")
    }
    
    scenario(s"only one `from_date` in URL") 
    {
      val httpRequestUrl= s"/obp/v3.1.0/management/metrics/top-consumers?from_date=$startDateString"
      val startdateValue = getHttpRequestUrlParam(httpRequestUrl,"from_date")
      startdateValue should be (s"$startDateString")
    }
    
    
    scenario(s"Both `from_date` and `to_date` in URL") 
    {
      val httpRequestUrl= s"httpRequestUrl = /obp/v3.1.0/management/metrics/top-consumers?from_date=$startDateString&to_date=$endDateString"
      val startdateValue = getHttpRequestUrlParam(httpRequestUrl,"from_date")
      startdateValue should be (s"$startDateString")
      val endDateValue = getHttpRequestUrlParam(httpRequestUrl,"to_date")
      endDateValue should be (s"$endDateString")
      val noneFieldValue = getHttpRequestUrlParam(httpRequestUrl,"none_field")
      noneFieldValue should be ("")
    }
    
    scenario(s"test some space in the URL, eg: /obp/v3.0.0/management/aggregate-metrics?app_name=API Manager Local Dev ") 
    {
      val httpRequestUrl= s"httpRequestUrl = /obp/v3.0.0/management/aggregate-metrics?app_name=API Manager Local Dev "
      val startdateValue = getHttpRequestUrlParam(httpRequestUrl,"app_name")
      startdateValue should be (s"API Manager Local Dev ")
    }
    
    
    scenario(s"test the error case, eg: not proper parameter name") 
    {
      val httpRequestUrl= s"httpRequestUrl = /obp/v3.1.0/management/metrics/top-consumers?from_date=$startDateString&to_date=$endDateString"
      val noneFieldValue = getHttpRequestUrlParam(httpRequestUrl,"none_field")
      noneFieldValue should be ("")
    }
  } 
  
  feature("test APIUtil.getHttpValues method") 
  {
    scenario("test the one value case in HTTPParam , eg: (one name : one value)") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("from_date",s"$DateWithMsExampleString"))
      val returnValue = getHttpValues(httpParams, "from_date")
      returnValue should be (List(s"$DateWithMsExampleString"))
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the many values case in HTTPParam, eg (one name : value1,value2,value3)") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("from_date", List(s"$DateWithMsExampleString",s"$DateWithMsExampleString")))
      val returnValue = getHttpValues(httpParams, "from_date")
      returnValue should be (List(s"$DateWithMsExampleString",s"$DateWithMsExampleString"))
    }
    
    
    scenario(s"test the many values case in HTTPParam, eg (exclude_app_names : value1,value2,value3)") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("exclude_app_names", List("value1","value2", "value3")))
      val returnValue = getHttpValues(httpParams, "exclude_app_names")
      returnValue should be (List("value1","value2", "value3"))
    }
    
    scenario(s"test error cases, get wrong name ") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("from_date", List(s"$DateWithMsExampleString",s"$DateWithMsExampleString")))
      val returnValue = getHttpValues(httpParams, "wrongName")
      returnValue should be (Empty)
    }
    
    scenario(s"test None case, httpParams == Empty ") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List.empty[HTTPParam]
      val returnValue = getHttpValues(httpParams, "wrongName")
      returnValue should be (Empty)
    }
  }
  
  feature("test APIUtil.parseObpStandardDate method") 
  {
    scenario(s"test the correct format- DateWithMsFormat") 
    {
      val correctDateFormatString = DateWithMsExampleString
      val returnValue: Box[Date] = parseObpStandardDate(correctDateFormatString)
      returnValue.isDefined should be (true)
      returnValue.openOrThrowException("") should be (DateWithMsFormat.parse(correctDateFormatString))
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the correct format- DateWithMsRollbackFormat") 
    {
      val correctDateFormatString = DateWithMsRollbackExampleString
      val returnValue: Box[Date] = parseObpStandardDate(correctDateFormatString)
      returnValue should be (Full(DateWithMsRollbackFormat.parse(correctDateFormatString)))
    }
    
    
    scenario(s"test the wrong data format") 
    {
      val returnValue: Box[Date] = parseObpStandardDate("2001.07-01T00:00:00.000+0000")
      returnValue.isDefined should be (false)
      returnValue.toString contains FilterDateFormatError should be (true)
    }
  }
  
  feature("test APIUtil.getSortDirection method") 
  {
    scenario(s"test the correct case: ASC or DESC") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("sort_direction", List("ASC")))
      val returnValue = getSortDirection(httpParams)
      returnValue.isDefined should be (true)
      returnValue.openOrThrowException("") should be (OBPAscending)
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the wrong case: wrong values (wrongValue) in HTTPParam") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("sort_direction", List("wrongValue")))
      val returnValue = getSortDirection(httpParams)
      returnValue.toString contains FilterSortDirectionError should be (true)
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the wrong case: wrong name (wrongName) in HTTPParam. It will return the default Sort Direction = DESC ") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("wrongName", List("ASC")))
      val returnValue = getSortDirection(httpParams)
      returnValue should be (Full(OBPDescending))
    }
  }

  implicit val fromDateOrdering = new Ordering[OBPFromDate] {
    override def compare(x: OBPFromDate, y: OBPFromDate): Int = if (x.value.after(y.value)) {
      1
    } else if(y.value.after(x.value)) {
      -1
    } else {
      0
    }
  }

  feature("test APIUtil.getFromDate method") 
  {
    scenario(s"test the correct case") 
    {
      val correctDateFormatString = s"$DateWithMsExampleString"
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("from_date", List(correctDateFormatString)))
      val returnValue = getFromDate(httpParams)
      returnValue should be (Full(OBPFromDate(DateWithMsFormat.parse(correctDateFormatString))))
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the wrong case: wrong values (wrongValue) in HTTPParam") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("from_date", List("wrongValue")))
      val returnValue = getFromDate(httpParams)
      returnValue.toString contains FilterDateFormatError should be (true)
    }
    
    scenario("test the wrong case: wrong name (wrongName) in HTTPParam")
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("wrongName", List(s"$DateWithMsExampleString")))
      val startTime = OBPFromDate(theEpochTime)
      val returnValue = getFromDate(httpParams)
      returnValue shouldBe a[Full[OBPFromDate]]

      val currentTime = OBPFromDate(theEpochTime)
      val beWithinTolerance = be  >= startTime and be <= currentTime
      returnValue.orNull should beWithinTolerance
    }
    
    scenario("test the wrong case: wrong name (wrongName) and wrong values (wrongValue) in HTTPParam")
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("wrongName", List("wrongValue")))
      val startTime = OBPFromDate(theEpochTime)
      val returnValue = getFromDate(httpParams)
      returnValue shouldBe a[Full[OBPFromDate]]

      val currentTime = OBPFromDate(theEpochTime)
      val beWithinTolerance = be  >= startTime and be <= currentTime
      returnValue.orNull should beWithinTolerance
    }
  }

  implicit val toDateOrdering = new Ordering[OBPToDate] {
    override def compare(x: OBPToDate, y: OBPToDate): Int = if (x.value.after(y.value)) {
      1
    } else if(y.value.after(x.value)) {
      -1
    } else {
      0
    }
  }

  feature("test APIUtil.getToDate method") 
  {
    scenario(s"test the correct case") 
    {
      val correctDateFormatString = s"$DateWithMsExampleString"
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("to_date", List(correctDateFormatString)))
      val returnValue = getToDate(httpParams)
      returnValue should be (Full(OBPToDate(DateWithMsFormat.parse(correctDateFormatString))))
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the wrong case: wrong values (wrongValue) in HTTPParam") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("to_date", List("wrongValue")))
      val returnValue = getToDate(httpParams)
      returnValue.toString contains FilterDateFormatError should be (true)
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the wrong case: wrong name (wrongName) in HTTPParam") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("wrongName", List(s"$DateWithMsExampleString")))

      val startTime = OBPToDate(DefaultToDate)

      val returnValue = getToDate(httpParams)
      returnValue shouldBe a[Full[OBPToDate]]

      val currentTime = OBPToDate(DefaultToDate)
      val beWithinTolerance = be  >= startTime and be <= currentTime
      returnValue.orNull should beWithinTolerance
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the wrong case: wrong name (wrongName) and wrong values (wrongValue) in HTTPParam") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("wrongName", List("wrongValue")))

      val startTime = OBPToDate(DefaultToDate)

      val returnValue = getToDate(httpParams)
      returnValue shouldBe a[Full[OBPToDate]]

      val currentTime = OBPToDate(DefaultToDate)
      val beWithinTolerance = be  >= startTime and be <= currentTime
      returnValue.orNull should beWithinTolerance
    }
  }
  
  feature("test APIUtil.getOffset method") 
  {
    scenario(s"test the correct case: offset = 100") 
    {
      val correctValue = "100"
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("offset", List(correctValue)))
      val returnValue = getOffset(httpParams)
      returnValue should be (Full(OBPOffset(100)))
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the wrong case: wrong values (wrongValue) in HTTPParam") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("offset", List("wrongValue")))
      val returnValue = getOffset(httpParams)
      returnValue.toString contains FilterOffersetError should be (true)
      
      val httpParams2: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("offset", List("-1")))
      val returnValue2 = getOffset(httpParams)
      returnValue2.toString contains FilterOffersetError should be (true)
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the wrong case: wrong name (wrongName) in HTTPParam") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("wrongName", List("100")))
      val returnValue = getOffset(httpParams)
      returnValue should be (OBPOffset(0))
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the wrong case: wrong name (wrongName) and wrong values (wrongValue) in HTTPParam") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("wrongName", List("wrongValue")))
      val returnValue = getOffset(httpParams)
      returnValue should be (OBPOffset(0))
    }
  }
  
  feature("test APIUtil.getLimit method") 
  {
    scenario(s"test the correct case: limit = 100") 
    {
      val correctValue = "100"
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("limit", List(correctValue)))
      val returnValue = getLimit(httpParams)
      returnValue should be (Full(OBPLimit(100)))
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the wrong case: wrong values (wrongValue) in HTTPParam") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("limit", List("wrongValue")))
      val returnValue = getLimit(httpParams)
      returnValue.toString contains FilterLimitError should be (true)
      
      val httpParams2: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("limit", List("-1")))
      val returnValue2 = getLimit(httpParams)
      returnValue2.toString contains FilterLimitError should be (true)
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the wrong case: wrong name (wrongName) in HTTPParam") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("wrongName", List("100")))
      val returnValue = getLimit(httpParams)
      returnValue should be (OBPLimit(Constant.Pagination.limit))
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the wrong case: wrong name (wrongName) and wrong values (wrongValue) in HTTPParam") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("wrongName", List("wrongValue")))
      val returnValue = getLimit(httpParams)
      returnValue should be (OBPLimit(Constant.Pagination.limit))
    }
  }
  
  feature("test APIUtil.getHttpParamValuesByName method") 
  {
    scenario(s"test the correct case, single value = anon") 
    {
      val correctValue = "true"
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("anon", List(correctValue)))
      val returnValue = getHttpParamValuesByName(httpParams, "anon")
      returnValue should be (Full(OBPAnon(true)))
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the correct case, exclude_app_names=API_EXPLOER,SOFIT") 
    {
      val correctValue = List("API_EXPLOER","SOFIT")
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("exclude_app_names", correctValue))
      val returnValue = getHttpParamValuesByName(httpParams, "exclude_app_names")
      returnValue should be (Full(OBPExcludeAppNames(correctValue)))
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the correct case2, multi values = anon,consumer_id") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("anon", "true"), HTTPParam("consumer_id", "1"))
      val returnValue = getHttpParamValuesByName(httpParams, "anon")
      returnValue should be (Full(OBPAnon(true)))
      val returnValue1 = getHttpParamValuesByName(httpParams, "consumer_id")
      returnValue1 should be (Full(OBPConsumerId("1")))
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the wrong case: wrong values (wrongValue) in HTTPParam") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("anon", List("wrongValue")))
      val returnValue = getHttpParamValuesByName(httpParams, "anon")
      returnValue.toString contains FilterAnonFormatError should be (true)
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the wrong case: wrong name (wrongName) in HTTPParam") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("wrongName", List("true")))
      val returnValue = getHttpParamValuesByName(httpParams, "anon")
      returnValue should be (Full(OBPEmpty()))
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the wrong case: wrong name (wrongName) and wrong values (wrongValue) in HTTPParam") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("wrongName", List("wrongValue")))
      val returnValue = getHttpParamValuesByName(httpParams, "anon")
      returnValue should be (Full(OBPEmpty()))
    }
  }
  
  feature("test APIUtil.getHttpParams method") 
  {
    val RetrunDefaultParams = Full(List(OBPLimit(Constant.Pagination.limit),OBPOffset(0),OBPOrdering(None,OBPDescending), OBPFromDate(startDateObject),OBPToDate(endDateObject)))
    
    scenario(s"test the correct case1: with default parameters") 
    {
      val ExpectResult = RetrunDefaultParams 
      
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(
        HTTPParam("from_date",List(s"$DefaultFromDateString")),
        HTTPParam("to_date",List(s"$DefaultToDateString"))
      )
      val returnValue = createQueriesByHttpParams(httpParams)
      returnValue should be (ExpectResult)
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the correct case2: contains the `anon` ") 
    {
      val ExpectResult = 
        Full(List(OBPLimit(Constant.Pagination.limit),OBPOffset(Constant.Pagination.offset),OBPOrdering(None,OBPDescending)
                  ,OBPFromDate(startDateObject),OBPToDate(endDateObject),
                  OBPAnon(true)))
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(
        HTTPParam("from_date",List(s"$DefaultFromDateString")),
        HTTPParam("to_date",List(s"$DefaultToDateString")),
        HTTPParam("anon", "true")
      )
      val returnValue = createQueriesByHttpParams(httpParams)
      returnValue should be (ExpectResult)
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the correct case3: contains the `anon` and `consumer_id` ") 
    {
      val ExpectResult = 
        Full(List(OBPLimit(Constant.Pagination.limit),OBPOffset(Constant.Pagination.offset),OBPOrdering(None,OBPDescending),
             OBPFromDate(startDateObject),OBPToDate(endDateObject),
             OBPAnon(true),OBPConsumerId("1")))
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(
        HTTPParam("from_date",List(s"$DefaultFromDateString")),
        HTTPParam("to_date",List(s"$DefaultToDateString")),
        HTTPParam("anon", "true"), 
        HTTPParam("consumer_id", "1")
      )
      val returnValue = createQueriesByHttpParams(httpParams)
      returnValue should be (ExpectResult)
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the correct case4: contains all the fields") 
    {
      val ExpectResult = 
        Full(List(OBPLimit(Constant.Pagination.limit), OBPOffset(Constant.Pagination.offset), OBPOrdering(None,OBPDescending),
                  OBPFromDate(startDateObject), OBPToDate(endDateObject),
                  OBPAnon(true), OBPConsumerId("1"), OBPUserId("2"), OBPUrl("obp/v1.2.1/getBanks"),
                  OBPAppName("PlaneApp"), OBPImplementedByPartialFunction("getBanks"),
                  OBPImplementedInVersion("v1.2.1"), OBPVerb("GET"), OBPCorrelationId("123"), OBPDuration(1000),
                  OBPExcludeAppNames(List("TrainApp", "BusApp")), OBPExcludeUrlPatterns(List("%/obp/v1.2.1%")),
                  OBPExcludeImplementedByPartialFunctions(List("getBank", "getAccounts"))))
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(
        HTTPParam("from_date",List(s"$DefaultFromDateString")),
        HTTPParam("to_date",List(s"$DefaultToDateString")),
        HTTPParam("anon", "true"), 
        HTTPParam("consumer_id", "1"), 
        HTTPParam("user_id", "2"), 
        HTTPParam("url", "obp/v1.2.1/getBanks"), 
        HTTPParam("app_name","PlaneApp"),
        HTTPParam("implemented_by_partial_function","getBanks"),
        HTTPParam("implemented_in_version","v1.2.1"),
        HTTPParam("verb","GET"),
        HTTPParam("correlation_id","123"),
        HTTPParam("duration","1000"),
        HTTPParam("exclude_app_names",List("TrainApp","BusApp")),
        HTTPParam("exclude_url_patterns","%/obp/v1.2.1%"),
        HTTPParam("exclude_implemented_by_partial_functions",List("getBank","getAccounts"))
      )
      val returnValue = createQueriesByHttpParams(httpParams)
      returnValue should be (ExpectResult)
    }
    
    
    scenario(s"test the wrong case: values (wrongValue)- limit in HTTPParam") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("limit", List("wrongValue")))
      val returnValue = createQueriesByHttpParams(httpParams)
      returnValue.toString contains FilterLimitError should be (true)
    }
    
    
    scenario(s"test the wrong case: wrong values - anon (wrongValue) in HTTPParam") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("anon", List("wrongValue")))
      val returnValue = createQueriesByHttpParams(httpParams)
      returnValue.toString contains FilterAnonFormatError should be (true)
    }
    
    
    scenario(s"test the wrong case: wrong values-offset(wrongValue) in HTTPParam") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("offset", List("wrongValue")))
      val returnValue = createQueriesByHttpParams(httpParams)
      returnValue.toString contains FilterOffersetError should be (true)
      
      val httpParams2: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("offset", List("-1")))
      val returnValue2 = createQueriesByHttpParams(httpParams)
      returnValue2.toString contains FilterOffersetError should be (true)
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the wrong case: wrong values - duration (wrongValue) in HTTPParam") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(
        HTTPParam("from_date",List(s"$DefaultFromDateString")),
        HTTPParam("to_date",List(s"$DefaultToDateString")),
        HTTPParam("duration", List("wrongValue"))
      )
      val returnValue = createQueriesByHttpParams(httpParams)
      returnValue.toString contains FilterDurationFormatError should be (true)
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the wrong case: wrong name (wrongName) in HTTPParam") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(
        HTTPParam("from_date",List(s"$DefaultFromDateString")),
        HTTPParam("to_date",List(s"$DefaultToDateString")),
        HTTPParam("wrongName", List("true"))
      )
      val returnValue = createQueriesByHttpParams(httpParams)
      returnValue should be (RetrunDefaultParams)
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the wrong case: wrong values (wrongValue) in HTTPParam") 
    {
      val httpParams: List[HTTPParam] = List(HTTPParam("to_date", List("wrongValue")))
      val returnValue = createQueriesByHttpParams(httpParams)
      returnValue.toString contains FilterDateFormatError should be (true)
    }
    
  }
  
  feature("test APIUtil.createHttpParamsByUrl method") 
  {
    val RetrunDefaultParams = Full(List(OBPLimit(Constant.Pagination.limit),OBPOffset(Constant.Pagination.offset),OBPOrdering(None,OBPDescending), OBPFromDate(startDateObject),OBPToDate(endDateObject)))
    
    scenario(s"test the correct case1: all the params are in the `URL` ") 
    {
      val ExpectResult = Full(List(HTTPParam("sort_direction",List("ASC")), HTTPParam("from_date",List(s"$DateWithMsExampleString")), 
                                   HTTPParam("to_date",List(s"$DateWithMsExampleString")), HTTPParam("limit",List("10")), HTTPParam("offset",List("3")), 
                                   HTTPParam("anon",List("false")), HTTPParam("consumer_id",List("5")), HTTPParam("user_id",List("66214b8e-259e-44ad-8868-3eb47be70646")), 
                                   HTTPParam("url",List("/obp/v3.0.0/banks/gh.29.uk/accounts/8ca8a7e4-6d02-48e3-a029-0b2bf89de9f0/owner/transactions")), 
                                   HTTPParam("app_name",List("MapperPostman")), HTTPParam("implemented_by_partial_function",List("getTransactionsForBankAccount")), 
                                   HTTPParam("implemented_in_version",List("v3.0.0")), HTTPParam("verb",List("GET")), HTTPParam("correlation_id",List("123")), 
                                   HTTPParam("duration",List("100")), 
                                   HTTPParam("exclude_app_names",List("API-EXPLORER","API-Manager","SOFI","null","SOFIT")), 
                                   HTTPParam("exclude_url_patterns",List("%25management/metrics%25","%management/aggregate-metrics%")), 
                                   HTTPParam("exclude_implemented_by_partial_functions",List("getMetrics","getConnectorMetrics","getAggregateMetrics")))) 
      
      val httpRequestUrl = "/obp/v3.0.0/management/aggregate-metrics?" +
        s"offset=3&" +
        s"limit=10&" +
        s"sort_direction=ASC&" +
        s"from_date=$DateWithMsExampleString&" +
        s"to_date=$DateWithMsExampleString&" +
        s"consumer_id=5&user_id=66214b8e-259e-44ad-8868-3eb47be70646&" +
        "implemented_by_partial_function=getTransactionsForBankAccount&" +
        "implemented_in_version=v3.0.0&" +
        "url=/obp/v3.0.0/banks/gh.29.uk/accounts/8ca8a7e4-6d02-48e3-a029-0b2bf89de9f0/owner/transactions&" +
        "verb=GET&" +
        "anon=false&" +
        "app_name=MapperPostman&" +
        "exclude_app_names=API-EXPLORER,API-Manager,SOFI,null,SOFIT&" +
        "exclude_url_patterns=%25management/metrics%25,%management/aggregate-metrics%&" +
        "exclude_implemented_by_partial_functions=getMetrics,getConnectorMetrics,getAggregateMetrics&"+ 
        "correlation_id=123&duration=100"
      val returnValue = createHttpParamsByUrl(httpRequestUrl)
      returnValue should be (ExpectResult)
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the correct case2: no parameters in the Url ") 
    {
      val ExpectResult = Full(List())
      val httpRequestUrl = "/obp/v3.0.0/management/aggregate-metrics"
      val returnValue = createHttpParamsByUrl(httpRequestUrl)
      returnValue should be (ExpectResult)
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the correct case3: some params are in the `URL` ") 
    {
      val ExpectResult = Full(List(HTTPParam("sort_direction",List("ASC")), HTTPParam("from_date",List(s"$DateWithMsExampleString")), 
                                   HTTPParam("to_date",List(s"$DateWithMsExampleString")), HTTPParam("limit",List("10")), HTTPParam("offset",List("3")), 
                                   HTTPParam("consumer_id",List("5")), HTTPParam("user_id",List("66214b8e-259e-44ad-8868-3eb47be70646")), 
                                   HTTPParam("implemented_by_partial_function",List("getTransactionsForBankAccount")), 
                                   HTTPParam("implemented_in_version",List("v3.0.0"))))
      val httpRequestUrl = "/obp/v3.0.0/management/aggregate-metrics?" +
        s"offset=3&limit=10&sort_direction=ASC&from_date=$DateWithMsExampleString&to_date=$DateWithMsExampleString&consumer_id=5&user_id=66214b8e-259e-44ad-8868-3eb47be70646&" +
        "implemented_by_partial_function=getTransactionsForBankAccount&implemented_in_version=v3.0.0"
      val returnValue = createHttpParamsByUrl(httpRequestUrl)
      returnValue should be (ExpectResult)
    }
    
    scenario(s"test the correct case4: error case None in `=` right side ") 
    {
      val ExpectResult = Full(List())
      val httpRequestUrl = s"/obp/v3.0.0/management/aggregate-metrics?from_date="
      val returnValue = createHttpParamsByUrl(httpRequestUrl)
      returnValue should be (ExpectResult)
    }
  }

  feature("test APIUtil.firstCharToLowerCase method") {
    APIUtil.firstCharToLowerCase("ABC") should be ("aBC")
    APIUtil.firstCharToLowerCase("") should be ("")
    APIUtil.firstCharToLowerCase(null) should be ("")
    APIUtil.firstCharToLowerCase("aaaa") should be ("aaaa")
  }

  /**
   * should add the follow to test.default.props
   * ## should be "hello_foo_bar__good luck__"
   * hello.world=hello_${foo.bar}__good ${greeting.${compose.exp}}__
   * foo.bar=foo_bar
   * compose.exp=word
   * greeting.word=luck
   */
  feature("test APIUtil.getPropsValue support expression") {
    setPropsValues(
      "hello.world" -> "hello_${foo.bar}__good ${greeting.${compose.exp}}__",
      "foo.bar" -> "foo_bar",
      "compose.exp" -> "word",
      "greeting.word" -> "luck"
    )
    APIUtil.getPropsValue("hello.world") should be("hello_foo_bar__good luck__")
  }

  feature("test APIUtil.getObpFormatOperationId method") {
    APIUtil.getObpFormatOperationId("OBPv4_0_0-dynamicEntity_deleteFooBar33") should be ("OBPv4.0.0-dynamicEntity_deleteFooBar33")
    APIUtil.getObpFormatOperationId("OBPv3.0.0-getCoreAccountById") should be ("OBPv3.0.0-getCoreAccountById")
    APIUtil.getObpFormatOperationId("xxx") should be ("xxx")
  }

}